Table 1. Simulation Time Schedule.

From: Effects of Hybrid Education Sequence on Learning Outcomes for Clinical Judgement Development in Nursing Students in the Developing Phase of Readiness

Time Task Action
5 min Orientation Scenario theme・Learning objective・Briefing
Pick students for simulation performance
5 min Check pre-assignment Gather information from electronic medical record and share for Learning objective 1
10 min 1st Simulation 1st performance for Learning objective 2
The rest of the students take notes on white boards.
10 min 1st Debriefing Perform based on anticipation and initial understanding
10 min 2nd Simulation 2nd performance for Learning objective 3
The rest of the students take notes on white boards.
10 min 2nd Debriefing Perform based on analytical inference pattern and action of clinical judgment
3 min 3rd Simulation 3rd performance for Learning objective 3
The rest of the students take notes on white boards.
5 min 3rd Debriefing Clinical judgment: Noticing, Interpreting, Responding, Reflection
2 min Conclusion Conclude toward learning objectives
Table 2. Comparison of Achievement in Eight Previously Studied Courses (Baseline Measurement).

From: Effects of Hybrid Education Sequence on Learning Outcomes for Clinical Judgement Development in Nursing Students in the Developing Phase of Readiness

n = 84
Group A Group B
Items Median (quartile deviation) Median (Q) p value
Specialized Fundamental Courses
 Anatomy Physiology M7.0 (Q1.5) M6.0 (Q1.5) 0.856
 Pathophysiology M6.0 (Q1.5) M6.0 (Q1.5) 0.859
 General theory of therapeutics M6.0 (Q1.0) M6.0 (Q1.5) 0.96
 Disease treatment M6.0 (Q1.0) M6.0 (Q1.5) 0.964
Specialized Courses
 Daily living assistance techniques M7.0 (Q1.5) M6.5 (Q1.5) 0.663
 Physical Assessment M6.5 (Q1.5) M7.0 (Q1.5) 0.495
 Assistive techniques for medical treatment M6.0 (Q1.5) M6.0 (Q1.0) 0.542
 Critical thinking, Nursing process M6.0 (Q1.5) M6.0 (Q1.0) 0.301
Table 3. Comparison of Lasater Clinical Judgment Rubric (LCJR) Scores.

From: Effects of Hybrid Education Sequence on Learning Outcomes for Clinical Judgement Development in Nursing Students in the Developing Phase of Readiness

n = 84
Items Group A Group B
Median (quartile deviation) Median (Q) p value
Included in effective noticing: Subtotal M8.0 (Q1.5) M7.0 (Q1.0) 0.852
 Focused observation M3.0 (Q0.5) M3.0 (Q0.5) 0.739
 Recognition of deviation from expected patterns M3.0 (Q0.5) M2.5 (Q0.5) 0.675
 Information searching M3.0 (Q0.5) M3.0 (Q0.5) 0.609
Included in effective interpreting: Subtotal M5.0 (Q1.0) M5.0 (Q1.0) 0.575
 Prioritization of data M3.0 (Q0.5) M3.0 (Q0.5) 0.371
 Making meaning of data M2.5 (Q0.5) M3.0 (Q0.5) 0.839
Included in effective responding: Subtotal M9.5 (Q2.0) M10.0 (Q1.5) 0.746
 Calm and confident attitude M2.0 (Q0.5) M2.5 (Q0.5) 0.464
 Clear communication M3.0 (Q0.5) M3.0 (Q0.5) 0.911
 Well-planned intervention and flexibility M2.5 (Q0.5) M2.0 (Q0.5) 0.282
 Being skilled M2.0 (Q0.5) M2.0 (Q0.5) 0.675
Included in effective reflection: Subtotal M4.5 (Q1.0) M5.0 (Q1.0) 0.906
 Evaluation, self-analysis M2.0 (Q0.5) M2.0 (Q0.5) 1.749
 Commitment to improvement M2.0 (Q0.5) M3.0 (Q0.5) 0.474
Rubric Total M27.0 (Q4.5) M27.0 (Q3.5) 0.702
Table 4. Comparison of Achievement Levels for Learning Goals in the Hybrid Class in CBE.

From: Effects of Hybrid Education Sequence on Learning Outcomes for Clinical Judgement Development in Nursing Students in the Developing Phase of Readiness

n = 84
Group A Group B
Median (quartile deviation) Median (Q) p value
Learning Objective 1【Pre-Assignment】 M7.0 (Q1.0) M7.0 (Q1.0) 0.953
Able to gather appropriate information from electronic medical record.
Learning Objective 2. M6.0 (Q1.0) M6.0 (Q1.0) 0.812
Able to explain the knowledge of anatomy and physiology necessary for clinical judgment.
Learning Objective 3. M6.0 (Q1.0) M6.0 (Q1.0) 0.859
Able to anticipate the condition of the subject, observe the condition with prioritizing, and initially understand the condition.
Learning Objective 4 M6.0 (Q1.0) M6.0 (Q1.5) 0.086
Able to interpret information from data obtained by observing the patient’s condition and respond as necessary (I-SBAR reporting and nursing assistance).
Learning Objective 5【Pre-Assignment】 M6.5 (Q1.0) M6.0 (Q1.0) 0.305
Able to reflect on the results and recognize the clinical judgment process.
PAGE TOP